Last Updated on May 5, 2026 by Brian Kachejian
Feature Photo and design by Brian Kachejian
Candy has always been one of the most competitive and nostalgic categories in food, but today the variety of flavors and brands has reached a level that makes choosing the best one harder than ever.
Candy is one of those categories that everyone thinks they know until you actually start putting different brands and flavors side by side. That is when things get interesting.
What started as a simple idea quickly turned into a full series of taste tests covering everything from chocolate classics to gummy favorites and even sugar-free options. Some of these delivered exactly what you would expect, while others completely surprised us in both directions.
These reviews are built on real tasting, real reactions, and honest scoring. No hype, no sponsorships, and no outside influence. Every product is judged on flavor, texture, and overall experience.
Below is a growing collection of our candy taste tests and rankings.
Russell Stover Sugar-Free Candy Ranked
A full breakdown of Russell Stover’s sugar-free chocolates, including mints, coconut, caramel, and peanut varieties. This test focuses on how closely these products resemble real candy and how far sugar-free options have come in recent years.
Sour Patch Kids Flavors Ranked
A detailed ranking of Sour Patch Kids flavors, including lemonade varieties, blue raspberry, peach, and watermelon. This test explores the balance between sour intensity and underlying sweetness.
Reese’s Big Cup Flavors Ranked
A full taste test of Reese’s Big Cup variations, examining how different fillings and textures impact the classic chocolate and peanut butter combination.
Haribo Goldbears Flavors Ranked
A breakdown of the iconic gummy bear flavors, focusing on texture, chew, and flavor clarity across the lineup.
Best Peppermint Candy Ranked
A comparison of peppermint candies evaluating freshness, intensity, and overall balance.
Best Red Licorice Brands Ranked
A side-by-side ranking of red licorice brands analyzing texture, chewiness, and flavor consistency.
Best Cookie Dough Bites Flavors Ranked
A taste test of cookie dough bite flavors focusing on sweetness, texture, and how closely they resemble real cookie dough.
Best Wiley Wallaby Licorice Flavors Ranked
A full ranking of Wiley Wallaby licorice flavors examining flavor strength and overall quality.
Which M&M’s Flavor Is the Best Ranked From Worst to First
A comprehensive ranking of M&M’s flavors looking at chocolate balance, texture, and overall appeal.
12 Incredible Canadian Candy Bars You’ve Probably Never Tried
A feature on unique Canadian candy bars highlighting lesser-known products and how they compare to familiar favorites.
This list will continue to grow as more candy taste tests are added. With so many brands and variations available today, there is always something new to try and compare.
If you are looking for honest candy reviews based on real taste tests, this is where you will find them.
