Last Updated on May 28, 2025 by Brian Kachejian

The Hamptons Culinary Elite: A Critic’s Guide to the Ten Best Tables

I. An Overture to Opulence: Dining in the Hamptons

The Hamptons Mystique: More Than Just a Zip Code

The Hamptons, that storied stretch of Long Island’s South Fork, conjures images of windswept dunes, shingled estates, and an undeniable aura of exclusivity. Yet, beyond the societal pages and celebrity sightings lies a culinary landscape as rich and diverse as its famous inhabitants. This is a place where the briny Atlantic air kisses fields of just-picked produce, where generations of farming and fishing traditions provide an unparalleled bounty for the table. The unique alchemy of seaside charm, agricultural heartland, and an affluent, discerning populace has cultivated a dining scene of remarkable caliber. It is a world where a rustic clam shack can achieve legendary status alongside a white-tablecloth temple of gastronomy helmed by a globally acclaimed chef. The rhythm of the Hamptons is distinctly seasonal, and its restaurants reflect this, with many blossoming in the summer sun, yet a resilient corps offers year-round delights for those who seek them.[1] Dining here is not merely about sustenance; it is an integral part of the Hamptons experience itself, a ritual woven into the very fabric of this celebrated enclave. The presence of a sophisticated, well-traveled clientele, often possessing considerable means, creates a fertile ground for culinary ambition. This demographic actively seeks out and supports top-tier dining experiences, which in turn attracts exceptional chefs, sommeliers, and restaurateurs, fostering an environment where significant investment in quality and innovation is not just possible, but expected. Consequently, the Hamptons’ culinary offerings are a direct reflection of this demand for excellence, allowing for the flourishing of establishments that can command premium pricing in exchange for world-class standards, including those led by chefs of international renown.[2, 3]

Furthermore, the culinary signature of the Hamptons is profoundly shaped by its “terroir”—a taste intrinsically linked to its specific geography and the rhythm of its seasons. While the “farm-to-table” philosophy is widespread, here it transcends trendiness, becoming a fundamental expression of identity. Given the region’s deep agricultural roots and its intimate relationship with the sea, chefs have at their disposal ingredients that tell the story of this particular place.[1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9] This focus on hyperlocal sourcing imbues the cuisine with an authenticity and a unique character that cannot be easily replicated, forming a significant part of the allure for diners who seek experiences deeply connected to the locale.

A Critic’s Pledge: Forging a List of Distinction

To curate a list of the “ten best” in such a vibrant arena is no small feat. It requires more than a fleeting glance at popular opinion or the latest buzz. The selections that follow are born from years of dedicated gastronomic exploration across the East End, a journey of countless meals, meticulous note-taking, and a relentless pursuit of that elusive alchemy that elevates dining to an art form. The guiding philosophy seeks authenticity, innovation where it enhances rather than distracts, unwavering consistency, and that ineffable quality—be it in the warmth of service, the soulfulness of a dish, or the transportive power of an atmosphere—that lingers long after the last bite. Each restaurant gracing this list has been personally vetted, its nuances savored, its story understood. The criteria are exacting: exceptional quality of food is paramount, supported by a distinctive and compelling taste profile, a memorable and fitting atmosphere, service that is both polished and perceptive, and a narrative—whether of long-standing tradition or bold new vision—that adds depth to the experience. This is not a compendium of fleeting trends, but a connoisseur’s collection of establishments that truly define the pinnacle of Hamptons dining.

II. The Hamptons Decem: A Connoisseur’s Collection

Topping Rose House (Jean-Georges): Where Pastoral Elegance Meets Culinary Brilliance

• The First Bite: A Critic’s Impression
  In the heart of Bridgehampton, Topping Rose House stands as a paragon of refined, farm-to-table dining, its culinary program orchestrated by the world-renowned Jean-Georges Vongerichten. This establishment is a masterful blend of 19th-century historic charm and sleek contemporary luxury, where each plate is a testament to the South Fork’s abundant harvest, elevated by culinary artistry of the highest order.[2, 3, 10] The association with a chef of Jean-Georges’ stature immediately confers an aura of exclusivity and an expectation of impeccable quality, drawing not only the hotel’s discerning guests but also destination diners from across the Hamptons and beyond. This synergy is a hallmark of luxury destinations globally and underscores the Hamptons’ position on the international culinary stage.
• The Star Performers: Signature Dishes & Specialties
  The menus at Jean-Georges at Topping Rose House are inherently seasonal, reflecting a deep commitment to the estate’s own one-acre farm and the finest offerings from local fishermen and producers.[2, 3] While specific dishes evolve, the Vongerichten signature is unmistakable: preparations that appear deceptively simple yet unfold with layers of complex, bright flavors. Breakfast, often a highlight for hotel guests, is consistently lauded for its freshness and artful execution.[10] One might encounter perfectly seared local fish, perhaps a delicate halibut or sea bass, often accompanied by nuanced herbal butters or vibrant vegetable accoutrements, reminiscent of Jean-Georges classics.[11] Innovative vegetable dishes, allowing the natural essence of the produce to shine, are also a hallmark. Though a global signature, the famed egg toast with caviar might grace the menu, offering a touch of iconic indulgence.[11] The culinary philosophy emphasizes purity of ingredients, often balanced by bright acidic notes or deeply savory sauces that enhance rather than mask.
• The Flavor Profile: A Symphony on the Palate
  The cuisine is a true embodiment of farm-to-table principles, delivering tastes that are clean, vibrant, and intensely ingredient-focused.[2, 3] The finesse of classical French technique is applied to the American bounty, often with those subtle, characteristic Asian grace notes that define Jean-Georges’ innovative style. Dishes are frequently described by patrons of his other establishments as “delicate but deeply flavorful,” a quality that resonates here amidst the Hamptons’ agricultural richness.[11]
• The Stage: Ambiance and Atmosphere
  The dining experience unfolds within a beautifully restored 19th-century mansion, seamlessly integrated with modern design elements.[2, 10] The restaurant’s interior, envisioned by Wolfgang Ludes, exudes a modern sensibility, with zinc and marble surfaces providing a sophisticated counterpoint to stone and reclaimed wood. The lighting, artfully conceived by Hervé Descottes, employs ceramic and wicker shades alongside Edison fixtures to cultivate an “understated beach-chic ambience”.[3] The overall feeling is one of “cozy and intimate” elegance [10], though the energy can be quite vibrant during peak times.[3] Forbes Travel Guide has recognized its “world-class dining program” set within a “stately” house that offers “unparalleled luxury”.[12]
• The Chronicle: A Storied Past
  Topping Rose House itself is a thoughtfully reimagined 19th-century estate.[2] The restaurant’s culinary direction is under the aegis of Chef Jean-Georges Vongerichten, a name that carries immense global prestige. Even prior to his direct oversight of the menu, the establishment demonstrated a commitment to high culinary standards, as evidenced by a James Beard Foundation “Hamptons Chic” dinner featuring the then-chef Ryan Murphy, who applied European technique to the East End’s seasonal bounty.[12] While a global brand, the success of this outpost is deeply intertwined with its capacity to authentically integrate the Hamptons’ farm-to-table ethos, a commitment underscored by the use of ingredients from its own on-site farm.[3]
• The Essentials: Know Before You Go
  • Cuisine: Modern American (Farm-to-Table with French technique)
  • Price Point: $$$$ (Special Occasion/Spare No Expense) [3, 13]
  • Location: 1 Bridgehampton-Sag Harbor Turnpike, Bridgehampton, NY 11932
  • Hours: Open year-round, serving breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Specific hours vary; reservations are essential.[2, 3]
  • Critic’s Highlight: The impeccable sourcing of ingredients, allowing a taste of Jean-Georges’ culinary philosophy translated through the unique lens of the Hamptons. Any seasonal fish preparation is invariably a masterclass in flavor and technique.

Nick & Toni’s: The Enduring Heartbeat of Hamptons Italian

• The First Bite: A Critic’s Impression
  For nearly three decades, Nick & Toni’s has transcended the mere definition of a restaurant to become an East Hampton institution. It is, for many, the “best restaurant on Long Island” [14], a hallowed ground where the Hamptons’ cognoscenti and discerning locals gather for rustic yet impeccably refined Italian-Mediterranean cuisine, served with an infectious air of convivial sophistication. Its longevity in the demanding Hamptons market speaks volumes about its consistent quality and deep community roots.
• The Star Performers: Signature Dishes & Specialties
  The heart of Nick & Toni’s kitchen is its wood-burning oven, which imparts a distinctive, smoky character to a significant portion of the menu.[4] The offerings evolve seasonally, guided by the yield of their on-premise organic garden and strong relationships with local farmers and fishermen.[4] Perennial favorites often include their wood-oven pizzas (traditionally offered Sunday through Thursday [4]), beautifully crafted pasta dishes such as a memorable Fettuccine with Shrimp [4], the iconic Penne alla Vecchia Bettola, crispy Zucchini Chips, and often a show-stopping Whole Roasted Fish. For a sweet conclusion, desserts like the shareable Nick & Toni’s Tartufo ($27.00) or the delicate Strawberry Sherbet Profiteroles ($16.00) are not to be missed.[4]
• The Flavor Profile: A Symphony on the Palate
  The culinary identity is firmly rooted in rustic Italian and Mediterranean traditions.[4] There is a profound emphasis on seasonal, organic ingredients, with many cultivated in their own one-acre garden just steps from the kitchen, a testament to Chef Joseph Realmuto’s commitment.[4, 15] Flavors are authentic, robust, and deeply comforting, yet executed with a precision and elegance that elevate them to a fine-dining plane.
• The Stage: Ambiance and Atmosphere
  The restaurant evokes “the air of an old farmhouse nestled in Tuscany”.[4] Its three dining rooms, all oriented around the central wood-burning oven, exude warmth and charm.[4] It is consistently described as a “neighborhood gem,” praised for its “great for outdoor dining” spaces, and often chosen for “romantic” occasions.[4] The atmosphere strikes a perfect balance: semi-formal enough for a special celebration, yet welcoming and relaxed, making it suitable for a variety of dining experiences.[4]
• The Chronicle: A Storied Past
  With a storied history spanning “almost three decades and counting” [14], Nick & Toni’s has cemented its position as a leader in Hamptons fine dining. Executive Chef Joseph Realmuto, a figure of considerable standing in the East End culinary scene, has been integral to the restaurant group for over two decades [15] and also provides culinary oversight for sister establishments like Coche Comedor.[16, 17] His culinary philosophy centers on the beauty of simple, seasonal ingredients handled with respect.[15] The restaurant has been a recipient of the Wine Spectator Award of Excellence (an accolade noted in 2007, likely maintained over the years [4]). Nick & Toni’s is a cornerstone of a respected restaurant family that includes Rowdy Hall, La Fondita, and Coche Comedor, each offering a different facet of the Hamptons dining experience but sharing a common commitment to quality.[1, 16, 17] This group structure allows for operational synergies and a consistent standard of excellence across diverse culinary concepts, effectively catering to a wide array of diner preferences within the Hamptons market.
• The Essentials: Know Before You Go
  • Cuisine: Italian-Mediterranean
  • Price Point: $$$ (Entrées typically $31 to $50, though this may be subject to change, indicating upscale dining) [4]
  • Location: 136 North Main Street, East Hampton, NY 11937 [4, 14]
  • Hours: Dinner served nightly. Seasonal hours apply: typically from 6:00 PM, with later closing times on weekends during peak season (May-September) versus the off-season. Reservations via Resy are highly recommended and often essential.[4, 14]
  • Critic’s Highlight: The elemental satisfaction of a dish kissed by the wood-fire, or a pasta showcasing the vibrant freshness of ingredients plucked from their own garden, all enjoyed within an atmosphere that feels like a timeless, welcoming Hamptons embrace.

Lulu Kitchen & Bar: Sag Harbor’s Sizzle of Wood-Fired Mediterranean Flair

• The First Bite: A Critic’s Impression
  Lulu Kitchen & Bar stands as a convivial, year-round cornerstone of Sag Harbor’s dining scene, a place where the primal allure of wood-fired cooking ignites Mediterranean vibrancy. It pulses with a bustling yet sophisticated energy, making it an enduring favorite for everything from sun-drenched leisurely lunches to animated, memorable dinners.[1, 18, 19] Its ability to be both a local staple and a destination reflects a keen understanding of Sag Harbor’s unique blend of relaxed charm and high expectations.
• The Star Performers: Signature Dishes & Specialties
  The heart and soul of Lulu’s menu is its impressive wood-burning grill and oven, which touch nearly every dish.[19] The Grilled Heirloom Cauliflower, dramatically presented and served with spicy roasted grapes and a white balsamic vinaigrette, is consistently cited as a “must-try” and a true signature.[1, 7] Wood-fired pizzas are another draw, with inventive options like the Khachapurri (adorned with egg, raclette, and a side of yogurt sauce) and the luxurious Trufata (featuring Stracciatella, exotic mushrooms, and truffle paste).[20] The flames also expertly char heartier fare, such as the Provençal-style whole branzino and a succulent 14-day dry-aged duck.[1, 7] A well-appointed raw bar offers glistening local and Canadian oysters, among other treasures of the sea.[7, 20]
• The Flavor Profile: A Symphony on the Palate
  The cuisine is a delightful exploration of Mediterranean flavors, all given a distinctive flair by the massive wood-burning hearth.[1] There’s a strong commitment to farmstand-fresh, seasonal ingredients, with produce sourced from esteemed local purveyors like Balsam Farms and impeccably fresh fish hailing from the nearby waters of Montauk.[7] Chef Philippe Corbet’s approach is often described as “French Touch, Sag Harbor Charm”; he masterfully channels his classical French training, experiences in the Middle East, and tenure in esteemed New York City kitchens into his cooking.[7, 21] His guiding philosophy is one of reverence for “great ingredients treated with respect,” a principle perfectly embodied by the elemental nature of wood-fire cooking.[21]
• The Stage: Ambiance and Atmosphere
  Lulu Kitchen & Bar offers an “intimate, brick-walled” interior, with an “often-packed, zinc-topped bar” that serves as a lively focal point.[1] The overall aesthetic is “sunny and sleek” [7], achieving a casual bistro feel with thoughtful design touches. French doors open onto bustling Main Street, while inside, comfy leather chairs and banquettes invite lingering. An open kitchen adds to the dynamism, and a “beautiful patio out to the back” provides a charming alfresco option.[19] This back patio, often described as shady and plant-filled, evokes distinct “Provençal vibes”.[7] The ambiance is consistently praised as “exemplary,” transporting diners to a Mediterranean state of mind.[19]
• The Chronicle: A Storied Past
  Lulu Kitchen & Bar first opened its doors in 2017.[7] It has been under the culinary direction of French-trained Chef Philippe Corbet since its inception. Corbet brings a wealth of experience from Michelin-starred establishments in his native France and notable New York City kitchens such as Bouley; his culinary lineage even includes a grandfather who earned two Michelin stars.[7, 19, 21] The impressive wine program, boasting a 275-selection list with a strong French focus (particularly Burgundy and Rhône), is overseen by corporate managing director Steven Jauffrineau and has earned Wine Spectator’s Award of Excellence.[7] Lulu is part of Alchemy Hospitality, a group that also operates the upscale Duryea’s seafood establishments on Long Island.[7] The distinct culinary signature, centered on wood-fired cooking, provides a memorable identity that draws patrons seeking that specific, elemental taste experience.
• The Essentials: Know Before You Go
  • Cuisine: Mediterranean (Wood-Fired)
  • Price Point: $$$ (Entrées generally range from $30-$56+, with some reviews noting it as “pricey” but worthwhile) [19, 20]
  • Location: 126 Main Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963 [18, 20]
  • Hours: Open seven days a week for lunch (from 12:00 PM) and dinner (from 5:30 PM); Sunday Brunch commences at 11:30 AM. A daily Happy Hour is available at the bar.[20]
  • Critic’s Highlight: The transformative magic of the wood fire, experienced through the iconic signature cauliflower or a perfectly grilled whole fish, ideally accompanied by a well-chosen French rosé enjoyed on their delightful patio.

Bostwick’s Chowder House: The Quintessential Taste of Hamptons Summer Seafood

• The First Bite: A Critic’s Impression
  Bostwick’s Chowder House is the very essence of Hamptons summertime dining distilled into one beloved institution. It’s a perennially popular, seaside-inspired sanctuary where the focus is squarely on impeccably fresh, local seafood, with their legendary lobster rolls and hearty chowders reigning supreme. The atmosphere is wonderfully unpretentious, the food consistently delicious, making it a cherished warm-weather ritual for families, beachcombers, and anyone seeking an authentic taste of classic coastal fare.[1, 22, 23, 24, 25] This enduring appeal in a luxury market underscores the power of authentic, high-quality casual dining.
• The Star Performers: Signature Dishes & Specialties
  The Lobster Roll at Bostwick’s is, without exaggeration, an icon. It’s frequently described as “super-filled and delicious” [22], even “unbelievable,” and noted for being “very reasonably priced” given the generous portions of succulent lobster meat.[22] Diners can choose between the classic chilled lobster salad roll or a decadent hot buttered version.[25] One enthusiastic reviewer declared, “the Lobster salad roll is unbelievable! My personal favorite in the Hamptons and elsewhere”.[22] Beyond this star, their creamy New England style chowder is a staple.[22] The menu is a greatest hits of seaside classics: baked stuffed clams, flavorful steamers, an array of locally caught fish, and excellent fish tacos (offered grilled or fried, complemented by roasted corn salsa and a zesty chipotle lime sauce [24]). Other favorites include tuna poke [24], crispy fried clams [1], the generous Fisherman’s Platter, and satisfying all-American burgers and fries.[22, 24]
• The Flavor Profile: A Symphony on the Palate
  The culinary approach is best described as “old-style comfort food” [22], where fresh, straightforward seafood is unequivocally the main event. The kitchen focuses on local catches and classic preparations that allow the natural, unadulterated flavors of the high-quality ingredients to shine through. The tastes are satisfying, deeply traditional, and avoid unnecessary complication, delivering precisely what one craves from a classic seaside meal.
• The Stage: Ambiance and Atmosphere
  The dining experience is defined by its “casual and laid-back” nature, with a “beachy and relaxed” vibe permeating the space.[22] Indoors, the decor is charmingly seaside-inspired, while the outdoor casual patio area, shaded by market umbrellas, is a prime spot for enjoying a meal in the Hamptons air.[23] The atmosphere is often “buzzing yet relaxed,” making it an ideal setting for “unwinding after a day in the Hamptons”.[24] The original Chowder House location is known for its no-frills, no-reservations-needed picnic tables, adding to its easygoing appeal.[1] (It’s worth noting its sister restaurant, Bostwick’s on the Harbor, offers a different experience with reservations and waterfront views [1, 26]).
• The Chronicle: A Storied Past
  Bostwick’s Chowder House has been a beloved fixture in the Hamptons seafood scene for a significant period, with sources indicating a history spanning over 18 years to as long as 30 years, with a founding around 1997.[27, 28] Longtime owners Chris Eggert and Kevin Boles are credited with establishing the restaurant’s loyal following, with Chris typically in the kitchen and Kevin overseeing the bar.[27, 28] More recently, Damien O’Donnell has joined as a Chef and Partner, particularly associated with the newer Bostwick’s on the Harbor location.[28] A key to their enduring success is consistency, with the owners always being present and upholding high standards for every dish.[28] The strategic brand extension with Bostwick’s on the Harbor allows them to cater to different dining preferences while leveraging their core reputation for quality seafood.
• The Essentials: Know Before You Go
  • Cuisine: American Seafood (Casual)
  • Price Point: $$ (Moderate Spend, with dishes like the lobster roll noted as “reasonably priced”) [22]
  • Location: 277 Pantigo Road, East Hampton, NY 11937 [23, 24, 25]
  • Hours: Primarily seasonal. Typically open daily for lunch and dinner throughout the summer season (e.g., 11:30 AM – 9:00 PM, Thursday-Sunday as a baseline, likely expanding to daily in peak summer).[23, 24]
  • Critic’s Highlight: The quintessential hot buttered lobster roll, savored on the sun-drenched patio on a perfect afternoon – it is the pure, unadulterated, and utterly joyful taste of Hamptons summer.

Il Buco al Mare: Amagansett’s Rustic Italian Seaside Romance

• The First Bite: A Critic’s Impression
  Il Buco al Mare gracefully transports the cherished, ingredient-centric ethos of its acclaimed New York City and Ibizan siblings to the shores of Amagansett. This inviting outpost offers a menu of beautiful simplicity, showcasing the best of local seafood and seasonal produce, often kissed by the flames of a wood-fired oven, creating a dining experience that is both relaxed and deeply satisfying.[5, 29, 30] The restaurant leverages the strong brand reputation of the Il Buco family, which began in NoHo in 1994 [31], providing an immediate draw for those familiar with its rustic-chic Italian dining and expectation of quality.
• The Star Performers: Signature Dishes & Specialties
  The menu champions ancient grain focaccias, perfect for tearing and sharing, alongside a curated selection of imported tinned fish—a delightful nod to its Spanish sister restaurant, Bottega il Buco in Ibiza.[5] The wood-burning oven plays a central role, charring and roasting seasonal local fare to perfection.[5, 30] While specific signature dishes for the Amagansett location are still building their legend, the Il Buco family is renowned for certain classics at its other venues, such as exquisitely crispy fried artichokes and a silken panna cotta [31]; these hint at the caliber and style one can anticipate. Expect elegantly simple seafood preparations that allow the freshness of the catch to take center stage.
• The Flavor Profile: A Symphony on the Palate
  The cuisine is the “telltale Il Buco ingredient driven” experience [5], rooted in the “beautiful simplicity of Italian cuisine”.[31] Flavors are coastal, bright, and impeccably fresh, designed to highlight the intrinsic quality of the local seafood and produce. The wine list is thoughtfully curated to complement this ethos, emphasizing offerings from coastal regions and “wines touched by the sea,” further enhancing the ‘al mare’ (by the sea) sensibility.[5] This focus on curated simplicity represents a form of luxury where the perfection of prime ingredients, minimally adorned, speaks volumes.
• The Stage: Ambiance and Atmosphere
  Il Buco al Mare offers a “warm, casual setting in the heart of Amagansett”.[5, 29] The atmosphere is intentionally “simple, relaxed” [5], likely exuding that effortlessly chic, rustic charm that is characteristic of the Il Buco brand. It’s a space designed for lingering, where the focus is on good food, good wine, and good company.
• The Chronicle: A Storied Past
  This Hamptons gem is the coastal outpost of the famed Il Buco family, a name synonymous with authentic Italian hospitality and cuisine since its flagship first opened as an antique store and café on Bond Street in 1994.[31] The Amagansett venture is particularly inspired by Bottega il Buco in Ibiza, Spain.[5] Chef Justin Smillie, notably associated with Il Buco Alimentari E Vineria in New York City, is celebrated for his seasonal Italian cooking that heavily features a wood-fired oven and Greenmarket produce.[32, 33] While his direct, day-to-day involvement at Il Buco al Mare is not explicitly detailed, his culinary DNA and philosophy are clearly resonant with the Amagansett restaurant’s approach.
• The Essentials: Know Before You Go
  • Cuisine: Italian (Coastal, Wood-Fired)
  • Price Point: $$$ (Likely upscale, reflecting its pedigree, quality, and Hamptons location)
  • Location: 231 Main Street, Amagansett, NY 11930 [5, 29]
  • Hours: Seasonal operation. An example of past hours includes Monday, Thursday-Sunday from 12:00 PM to 9:00 PM or 10:00 PM, with closures on Tuesdays and Wednesdays.[5] Reservations are managed via Resy.[29]
  • Critic’s Highlight: Sharing a rustic, ancient grain focaccia alongside impeccably fresh, wood-roasted local fish, paired with a crisp, well-chosen coastal Italian white wine – a pure taste of the sea.

Coche Comedor: Amagansett’s Vibrant Mexican Fiesta by Way of Fine Dining

• The First Bite: A Critic’s Impression
  From the highly respected team that brought the Hamptons enduring favorites like Nick & Toni’s, Coche Comedor dramatically elevates Mexican cuisine in Amagansett. This vibrant establishment has ingeniously transformed a historic diner car into a colorful, artful, and perpetually festive destination, serving “blazingly fresh and boldly imagined” dishes that redefine expectations for Mexican fare in the East End.[1, 17] It successfully takes a cuisine often associated with casualness and imbues it with the creativity and precision of fine dining.
• The Star Performers: Signature Dishes & Specialties
  The experience often begins with their exceptional house-made chips accompanied by a trio of terrific salsas: a bright verde, a smoky chipotle, and a classic tomato.[17] The menu shines with standout main courses such as the succulent rotisserie duck glazed with apricot-tamarind, and tender chicken adobo enriched with a complex mole negro.[17] Pork dishes are a highlight, particularly the wood-grilled pork carnitas, so tender they practically fall from the bone, and the deeply flavored pork barbacoa, perfect for tucking into hand-pressed tortillas.[17] Seafood is not overlooked, with a singular cod al pastor featuring grilled pineapple and a creamy avocado crema, and a daily roasted local fish, often black sea bass, prepared with pickled vegetables.[17] The dessert program, under Pastry Chef Kelsey Longley, offers delights like the ultimate coconut tres leches cake and a fabulous sundae with horchata ice cream and crisp churros.[17] The beverage program is equally compelling, with an extensive list of tequilas and mezcals, and creative margaritas such as the “Smoke & Embers” and the refreshing “Watermelon”.[34]
• The Flavor Profile: A Symphony on the Palate
  The cuisine is proudly “Inspired Mexican Cuisine” [16], characterized as “blazingly fresh and boldly imagined”.[17] Diners can expect authentic regional Mexican flavors, thoughtfully reinterpreted with a focus on high-quality, often local ingredients, all executed with a remarkable degree of fine-dining precision and flair.
• The Stage: Ambiance and Atmosphere
  The ambiance is consistently described as “colorful, artful, festive”.[17] Housed in the shell of the former Honest Diner, Coche Comedor retains some charming vintage elements like stainless steel accents and the classic rounded diner ceiling. However, the space has been brilliantly reimagined with vivid geometric floor tiles, whimsically designed tabletops that evoke abstracted avocados, and striking arched metal and tile mirrors. Folk art hands holding hearts and evocative images of Frida Kahlo further enhance the vibrant, art-filled atmosphere.[17] It achieves a chic yet casual feel, welcoming and energetic.
• The Chronicle: A Storied Past
  Coche Comedor was brought to life by the esteemed restaurant group also responsible for Hamptons institutions Nick & Toni’s, Rowdy Hall, and the adjacent, more casual taqueria, La Fondita.[1, 16, 17] The culinary vision is guided by Executive Chef Joseph Realmuto (of Nick & Toni’s fame) and Chef de Cuisine Juan Geronimo, with Pastry Chef Kelsey Longley contributing her sweet artistry.[17] The restaurant occupies the building that once housed the Honest Diner, a fondly remembered 1990s establishment from the very same ownership, making this venture a creative reincarnation.[17] The reported “no reservations” policy [17], if still in effect, is a deliberate choice that cultivates a spontaneous, buzzy atmosphere, distinguishing it from its more formal sister restaurant, Nick & Toni’s.
• The Essentials: Know Before You Go
  • Cuisine: Mexican (Refined, Regional)
  • Price Point: $$-$$$ (This range is suggested, offering high quality at a more accessible price point than some of its fine-dining peers, yet still reflecting its elevated nature) [17]
  • Location: 74A Montauk Hwy, Amagansett, NY 11930 [16, 34]
  • Hours: The bar typically opens from noon, featuring a raw bar menu. Dinner service is nightly, for example, from 5:30 PM to 10:00 PM or 11:00 PM. Notably, one review mentioned no reservations are taken [17], a key factor for planning a visit.
  • Critic’s Highlight: The unforgettable rotisserie duck with its shimmering apricot-tamarind glaze, followed by the ethereal coconut tres leches cake, all animated by a perfectly crafted, top-shelf margarita.

Carissa’s The Bakery: Where Artistry, Baking, and Community Knead Together

• The First Bite: A Critic’s Impression
  Carissa’s The Bakery, particularly its inviting Pantigo Road café in East Hampton, is far more than a mere bakery. It is a James Beard Award-winning culinary touchstone, a vibrant community hub where exquisite European-style breads, visually stunning pastries, and wholesome, locally-minded café fare are crafted with palpable artistry and an unwavering commitment to sustainable practices.[1, 6, 35, 36] It has successfully transcended the traditional bakery model to become a lifestyle brand, resonating deeply with a clientele that values quality, design, and ethical sourcing.
• The Star Performers: Signature Dishes & Specialties
  The foundation of Carissa’s acclaim lies in its exceptional European-style breads, including remarkable sourdough and distinctive pickled rye loaves.[1] Their croissants are legendary, earning the devotion of no less an authority than Ina Garten.[36] The Jambon Beurre sandwich is a classic, often selling out early [36, 37], while the Mortadella Sandwich ($15-$16) is praised for its exceptional flavor.[37, 38] For lighter fare, the Seasonal Market Salad is a vibrant choice [37, 39], and for breakfast, the Shakshuka is a standout [1], alongside a popular Avocado Toast.[37, 39] The pastry case is a gallery of edible art, featuring “vibrant cakes” [6], exquisite Pain au Chocolat, and creative cookies like the Miso Chocolate Chunk.[39, 40] Housemade gelato offers a cool treat [1], and for those looking to take Carissa’s home, dinner-to-go options such as Roasted Chicken and Salmon are available.[39]
• The Flavor Profile: A Symphony on the Palate
  The culinary philosophy centers on “wholesome ingredients that honor the season”.[6] European baking techniques are masterfully applied, often with a creative, local inspiration. The result is food that is both “delicious, and healthful”.[6] Savory dishes are characterized by their freshness and often an inventive twist, while the pastries are a triumph of both visual beauty and textural perfection.
• The Stage: Ambiance and Atmosphere
  The Pantigo Road location (221 Pantigo Road) is the primary dine-in venue, offering a “bright and sunny, modernist space”.[6] The aesthetic is one of “minimalism and beauty,” defined by “clean lines, tasteful decor, and vibrant flowers” that create an inviting and relaxing environment.[38] A long communal farm table is a feature at this location, encouraging a sense of community.[1] (Other outposts, such as Newtown Lane and Sag Harbor, primarily serve as take-out locations [35]). The importance of design is underscored by its James Beard Award for Restaurant Design, highlighting how aesthetics enhance the overall experience even in a café setting.[6]
• The Chronicle: A Storied Past
  Carissa’s was co-founded by the talented Pastry Chef and Baker Carissa Waechter [1, 6] and Lori Chemla.[6] The venture beautifully evolved from “something as ‘simple’ as baking bread” into a highly respected, locally-minded kitchen and community gathering place.[6] The business is deeply committed to responsible practices, including minimizing waste and thoughtfully sourcing ingredients from local growers who prioritize organic, sustainable, and fair-trade methods.[6] This dedication to quality and design has earned significant accolades: a 2020 James Beard Foundation Award for Outstanding Restaurant Design, and a 2025 James Beard semifinalist nod for Outstanding Bakery.[6] Its devoted following includes culinary icon Ina Garten, who is a noted fan of their offerings.[36]
• The Essentials: Know Before You Go
  • Cuisine: Bakery, Café (Modern American/European, Locally Sourced)
  • Price Point: $$-$$$ (Sandwiches range from $15-$18, dinner-to-go options $60-$75. Pastries vary. One review noted bottled water as $7) [37, 38, 39, 40]
  • Location (for dine-in focus): 221 Pantigo Road, East Hampton, NY 11937 [1, 35, 38]
  • Hours (Pantigo Road location): Typically Thursday-Sunday, 8:30 AM to approximately 3:00 PM/3:30 PM, offering bakery, restaurant, beverage, and pantry items for both dine-in and take-out.[35] While weekend dinner service was noted in the past [1], current information emphasizes daytime operations.
  • Critic’s Highlight: A perfectly laminated, buttery croissant to start, followed by their renowned Mortadella sandwich, savored within the beautifully designed, light-filled space of the Pantigo café.

Highway Restaurant & Bar: East Hampton’s Urbane Crossroads of New American and Global Flavors

• The First Bite: A Critic’s Impression
  Highway Restaurant & Bar provides a reliably sophisticated yet comfortably inviting New American dining experience in East Hampton. It’s a place where seasonally inspired cuisine is executed with an urban polish and intriguing global grace notes—often with an Asian inclination—making it a consistent favorite for a meticulously crafted meal, any night of the week.[1, 41, 42, 43] The restaurant’s association with a hospitality group known for New York City culinary titans, and a chef with similar high-caliber experience, brings an implicit assurance of quality and finesse.
• The Star Performers: Signature Dishes & Specialties
  The menu features several perennial standouts, including the succulent spit-roasted organic chicken [1, 44] and a tender, perfectly cooked ribeye.[1] Housemade pastas, such as Rigatoni and Trofie, are consistently well-received.[44, 45] A unique draw is their “Asian Night Mainstays,” which might include flavorful Thai Chicken Stir Fry, addictive Korean Chicken Buns (praised as “out of this world” pork buns in one review [43]), and a refreshing Papaya & Crab Salad.[44] Their Classic Cheeseburger is another popular choice for those craving expertly executed comfort food.[44] Should an ice cream sandwich appear on the specials list, it is highly recommended.[1]
• The Flavor Profile: A Symphony on the Palate
  The culinary approach is rooted in seasonally inspired New American cuisine, thoughtfully infused with urban sophistication and distinct global influences.[41, 42, 43] This can manifest as classic American bistro fare one evening, and then pivot to specific Thai or other Asian-inspired dishes on another, showcasing versatility.[43, 44, 45] A common refrain from satisfied diners is the sentiment of “Top-quality ingredients + expert preparation = delectable dinner!” [42], underscoring the kitchen’s commitment to excellence. This ability to offer a diverse yet consistently high-quality menu makes it a reliable choice for various tastes and repeat visits.
• The Stage: Ambiance and Atmosphere
  Highway Restaurant & Bar cultivates an atmosphere where “guests feel at home”.[41, 42] It’s often described as a “good looking place with a nice bar area” [42], and has earned descriptors such as “innovative,” “neighborhood gem,” and “romantic”.[42, 43] While the exterior might appear unassuming, the interior is characterized as “warm and hearty”.[43] The noise level can be “energetic,” particularly during peak dining times.[43]
• The Chronicle: A Storied Past
  Highway Restaurant & Bar is owned and managed by TOMS Hospitality, a distinguished fine dining restaurant group. Their impressive portfolio has included (either currently or formerly) some of New York City’s most acclaimed establishments, such as Eleven Madison Park, the NoMad Hotel’s restaurant, Shuko, and Charlie Bird.[1, 41] This pedigree implies a deeply ingrained culture of culinary and operational excellence. The kitchen is helmed by Executive Chef Anand Sastry, a culinary professional with a notable background that includes experience at the Michelin three-star Troisgros in France and Eleven Madison Park in New York City.[46, 47] The venue has also previously hosted a pop-up of the renowned sushi concept, Shuko Beach.[45]
• The Essentials: Know Before You Go
  • Cuisine: New American (Contemporary, with notable Asian influences)
  • Price Point: $$$$ (Designated as “$50 and over”) [42, 43]
  • Location: 290 Montauk Hwy, East Hampton, NY 11937 [41, 43, 44]
  • Hours: Dinner service is typically available Monday, and Wednesday through Sunday, from 5:00 PM to 9:00 PM. The restaurant is generally closed on Tuesdays.[42, 43]
  • Critic’s Highlight: The flawlessly executed spit-roasted chicken is a testament to their mastery of classics, while an exploration of their “Asian Night” specials offers an exciting glimpse into their global culinary finesse.

The 1770 House: East Hampton’s Grand Dame of Historic Charm and Contemporary Cuisine

• The First Bite: A Critic’s Impression
  The 1770 House is an undeniable landmark in East Hampton, an historic inn where Chef Michael Rozzi’s refined contemporary American cooking offers patrons two distinct yet equally compelling dining experiences. Upstairs, in the main dining room and on the seasonal patio, one finds sophisticated fine dining, while the cozy downstairs Tavern serves impeccably prepared, upscale pub fare. It is a place where centuries of history meet modern culinary artistry.[1, 48, 49, 50] This dual offering cleverly caters to varied moods and occasions, broadening its appeal without compromising its esteemed brand of quality.
• The Star Performers: Signature Dishes & Specialties
  In the main dining room, Chef Rozzi’s frequently changing menu showcases seasonal elegance. Past highlights have included exquisite Montauk fluke tartare, perfectly seared tuna, Montauk striped bass accompanied by a delicate lobster sauce, and expertly roasted halibut.[50] Another notable entrée has been a maple soy cured pork rib chop.[48] Down in the more casual Tavern, the undisputed star is the famous Meatloaf, a dish so beloved it earned the enthusiastic endorsement of Ina Garten.[1, 36] This iconic meatloaf is traditionally served with spinach, creamy potato puree, and a rich garlic sauce.[36] For dessert, offerings like a luscious ricotta cheesecake or a creative tres leches cake have graced the menu.[50]
• The Flavor Profile: A Symphony on the Palate
  The cuisine is defined by the “refined, understated New American cooking” of Chef Michael Rozzi.[49, 50] There is a clear emphasis on high-quality local and seasonal ingredients, with mentions of Montauk fluke and produce from local purveyors like Balsam Farms.[50] The main dining room presents sophisticated, often complex dishes that speak of fine dining technique, while the Tavern offers elevated comfort food executed with the same commitment to quality and flavor.
• The Stage: Ambiance and Atmosphere
  The main dining room offers a sophisticated fine dining environment, complemented by a seasonal patio for alfresco enjoyment.[49] Service in this space is often described as “exceptional,” with an overall “excellent” ambiance.[50] The downstairs Tavern provides a more casual, cozy atmosphere, perfect for enjoying traditional pub fare in a historic setting.[49] The entire establishment is housed within a charming historic inn, with the building itself dating back to 1663 and officially converted to an inn in the year 1770.[36, 48] This deep history provides a unique and memorable backdrop that enhances the dining experience.
• The Chronicle: A Storied Past
  The 1770 House proudly stands as one of Long Island’s top-rated restaurants and most historic country inns.[49] The building’s origins trace back to 1663, making it a true piece of American history.[48] Chef Michael Rozzi is a respected veteran of the East Hampton culinary scene, known for his excellent fare and previous tenure at the well-regarded, now-departed Della Femina.[50] The dining experience is expertly overseen by General Manager Carol Covell, ensuring polished service.[50] The restaurant has garnered praise from notable figures like Ina Garten for its meatloaf [1, 36] and has been featured in publications such as The New York Times.[48]
• The Essentials: Know Before You Go
  • Cuisine: Contemporary American (Fine Dining & Upscale Tavern Fare)
  • Price Point: $$$-$$$$ (Reflecting the fine dining nature of the main restaurant) [50]
  • Location: 143 Main Street, East Hampton, NY 11937 [51]
  • Hours: Typically open every day for dinner, with service starting at 5:30 PM.[50] Reservations are highly recommended.
  • Critic’s Highlight: Indulging in Chef Rozzi’s elegant and seasonally driven tasting menu in the refined main dining room for a truly special occasion, or opting for Ina Garten’s favorite meatloaf in the historic, convivial Tavern for a cozier yet equally memorable meal.

Gigi’s Montauk (at Gurney’s Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa): The New Wave of Seaside Steakhouse Chic

• The First Bite: A Critic’s Impression
  Arriving in the Summer of 2025 and replacing the long-standing Scarpetta Beach, Gigi’s Montauk is poised to make a significant splash as the first-ever flagship restaurant at the iconic Gurney’s Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa. This new venture promises a sophisticated New American steakhouse experience with a strong and vital seafood focus, all set against Gurney’s legendary, unparalleled ocean vistas. This launch marks a notable evolution for one of the Hamptons’ most landmark resorts and signals an ambitious new culinary direction.[52, 53, 54] This strategic rebranding underscores the dynamism of the Hamptons dining scene, where even established venues must innovate.
• The Star Performers: Signature Dishes & Specialties
  As a brand-new establishment (slated to open for service on June 16, 2025 [52]), specific signature dishes are yet to emerge from widespread critical review. However, the stated culinary direction is a “new American style steakhouse with a strong focus on seafood”.[52] Given its prestigious Gurney’s location and flagship status, one can anticipate exceptionally high-quality ingredients, prime cuts of meat, and impeccably fresh seafood, all presented with considerable culinary artistry.
• The Flavor Profile: A Symphony on the Palate
  The anticipated flavor profile will revolve around New American steakhouse classics, likely prepared with modern culinary sensibilities and techniques, alongside a prominent selection of expertly handled seafood dishes. The restaurant aims to embody “coastal charm meets seasonal innovation” [54], suggesting a menu that is both comforting in its steakhouse familiarity and exciting in its contemporary American and seafood-centric interpretations.
• The Stage: Ambiance and Atmosphere
  Gigi’s is situated within the renowned Gurney’s Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa [52, 53, 55, 56, 57], a destination celebrated for its “sweeping ocean views” [57] and a generally “lively atmosphere”.[10] Gurney’s itself projects a “Contemporary Classic & Lively” vibe [55] and is widely regarded as a destination for a true “luxury escape”.[10] Gigi’s will inherit the prime, highly coveted beachfront restaurant space previously occupied by Scarpetta Beach [52, 57], ensuring breathtaking views are integral to the dining experience. The restaurant faces the considerable expectation of being a destination within a destination, needing to draw patrons beyond the resort’s captive audience.
• The Chronicle: A Storied Past (and a New Chapter)
  Gurney’s Montauk boasts a rich history, having first opened its doors in 1926 [53] and serving as a Montauk institution for over 90 years.[55] Gigi’s represents a bold new chapter, launching in Summer 2025 as the resort’s “first-ever flagship restaurant”.[53] It takes the place of Scarpetta Beach, which was a popular and well-regarded Italian restaurant at Gurney’s for many years.[48, 55, 57, 58] The new restaurant will be helmed by Chef Jason Lee.[52] This transition signifies a deliberate strategic shift in Gurney’s overall dining program, aiming to establish a new signature culinary identity for the resort.
• The Essentials: Know Before You Go
  • Cuisine: New American Steakhouse & Seafood
  • Price Point: $$$$ (Anticipated to be in the highest tier, reflecting its Gurney’s resort setting, steakhouse concept, and seafood offerings)
  • Location: 290 Old Montauk Highway, Montauk, NY 11954 (located within Gurney’s Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa) [52, 55, 59, 60]
  • Hours: Opening Summer 2025. Reservations are set to begin on June 1, with full service commencing on June 16.[52] It will likely offer dinner service, with the potential for lunch depending on seasonal demand. Patrons should consult Gurney’s or Gigi’s official channels for precise operating hours.
  • Critic’s Highlight: The anticipation of being among the first to experience this new flagship, eager to discover how Chef Jason Lee will meld classic steakhouse traditions with the vibrant bounty of Montauk’s fresh seafood, all while framed by Gurney’s legendary, soul-stirring ocean views.

The Hamptons Decem: At-A-Glance

III. A Final Taste: The Ever-Evolving Hamptons Palate

The Enduring Allure and Constant Evolution

The Hamptons dining scene, as showcased by these ten exemplary establishments, is a captivating tapestry woven from threads of history, innovation, local bounty, and world-class talent. It is a realm of remarkable diversity, where historic inns serving contemporary cuisine stand shoulder-to-shoulder with chic new entrants redefining culinary genres, and where beloved casual seafood shacks command as much devotion as temples of high gastronomy. The common denominators across this varied landscape are an unwavering commitment to quality, a profound respect for locally sourced ingredients whenever possible, and an innate understanding of a clientele that is both discerning and appreciative of excellence. Yet, this is no static portrait. The Hamptons is a culinary landscape in perpetual, graceful motion, continuously reinventing itself while steadfastly honoring its rich roots. The strategic shift at Gurney’s with the introduction of Gigi’s Montauk [52, 53], and the flourishing of multifaceted concepts like Carissa’s The Bakery from a simple bread baker to a James Beard-recognized culinary hub [1, 35], are testaments to this vibrant evolution. This dynamism ensures that the Hamptons remains not just a premier summer destination, but a significant and ever-engaging culinary force. The region adeptly absorbs broader culinary trends—be it the enduring farm-to-table movement, the rise of artisanal baking, or the nuanced elevation of ethnic cuisines—but interprets them through its own distinct “Hamptons lens.” This local adaptation considers the seasonal resort economy, the desire for fresh seafood, and a unique social fabric, resulting in a dining scene that is both globally current and deeply, authentically place-specific.

Beyond the List: A Call to Exploration

While the ten restaurants detailed herein represent, from this critic’s extensive experience, the crème de la crème of Hamptons dining, they are but luminous stars in a wider constellation of culinary adventures. The East End is dotted with countless other eateries, from hidden gems to bustling bistros, each offering its own unique flavor and charm. This guide is intended not as a definitive, immutable decree, but as an informed and passionate starting point. It is an invitation to embark upon one’s own gastronomic journeys, to explore the diverse villages and hamlets, and to discover the personal favorites that will undoubtedly emerge.

A Critic’s Last Word

What ultimately makes dining in the Hamptons a truly special, often unforgettable experience is the remarkable confluence of elements. It is the profound beauty of the natural surroundings—the salty tang of the ocean air, the soft light over agricultural fields—that provides an unparalleled backdrop. It is the exceptional quality of the ingredients, drawn from the fertile land and bountiful sea, that forms the soul of the cuisine. It is the presence of immensely talented and dedicated chefs, restaurateurs, and service professionals who translate this bounty into moments of delight. And finally, it is the unique, palpable energy of this iconic destination, a place where relaxation and sophistication dance in effortless harmony. The top-tier restaurants here operate in a high-stakes environment where significant accolades and renowned chefs create towering expectations.[4, 6, 7, 12, 61] This “invisible hand” of expectation demands unwavering consistency, as a stellar reputation is both a precious commodity and a rigorous taskmaster. The establishments that not only endure but truly thrive are those that masterfully meet and exceed these elevated expectations, skillfully blending culinary craft with the art of hospitality at an elite level, ensuring the Hamptons’ palate remains as discerning and delighted as ever.

                                                                  Sources

1. Bostwick’s Chowder House – Dinner Menu: https://bostwickschowderhouse.com/dinner-menu

2. Reddit – Fine Dining Discussion (NYTimes): https://www.reddit.com/r/finedining/comments/1efy5t6/another_odd_take_on_fine_dining_by_the_nytimes/

3. Kissaki – Our Menu: https://explorekissaki.com/our-menu/

4. Bostwick’s Chowder House – Resy Menu: https://bostwicks-chowder-house.res-menu.com/menu

5. Reddit – FoodNYC Hamptons Discussion: https://www.reddit.com/r/FoodNYC/comments/13zk2a7/hamptons/

6. Frette – Featured Hotel: The 1770 House: https://www.frette.com/en_US/featured-hotel?fid=us-new-york-the-1770-house

7. OpenTable – Jean-Georges at Topping Rose House: https://www.opentable.com/r/jean-georges-at-topping-rose-house-bridgehampton

8. Dan’s Papers – Chef Anand Sastry (Highway Restaurant, 2020): https://www.danspapers.com/2020/12/chef-anand-sastry-highway-restaurant/

9. Dan’s Papers – Food Seen: Highway Chef (2021): https://www.danspapers.com/2021/09/food-seen-highway-chef-noyac-dining/

10. Modern Luxury – Damien O’Donnell (Bostwick’s): https://www.modernluxury.com/damien-o-donnell-bostwicks/

11. Grubhub – Lulu Kitchen & Bar Menu: https://www.grubhub.com/restaurant/lulu-kitchen-and-bar–126-main-street-sag-harbor/7141832

12. Forbes Travel Guide – 8 Hot Hamptons Restaurants: https://stories.forbestravelguide.com/8-hot-hamptons-restaurants-to-try-any-time-of-year

13. TikTok – Forbes Functions (Hamptons): https://www.tiktok.com/@forbesfunctions/video/7499243971701443871

14. OpenTable – Highway Restaurant and Bar: https://www.opentable.com/highway-restaurant-and-bar

15. YouTube – Hamptons Eater Review: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DIHmqnLYyy0

16. Goldbelly – Carissa’s The Bakery: https://www.goldbelly.com/restaurants/carissas-the-bakery

17. DoorDash – Highway Restaurant & Bar Menu: https://www.doordash.com/en/store/highway-restaurant-and-bar-east-hampton-116238/

18. Kissaki – Press: https://explorekissaki.com/press/

19. Sideways.nyc – Nick & Toni’s Cafe: https://sideways.nyc/discover/6fuaM0FbzM0O2X8pSdxWSc/nick-tonis-cafe

21. Hamptons.com – Long Island Restaurant Week Guide 2025: https://hamptons.com/2025-long-island-restaurant-week-winter-edition-guide/

22. Hamptons.com – Interview with Nick & Toni’s Chef: https://hamptons.com/delicious-seasonally-inspired-an-interview-with-nick-tonis-chef-de-cuisine/

23. Yahoo Lifestyle – Best Hamptons Restaurants Summer 2025: https://www.yahoo.com/lifestyle/best-hamptons-restaurants-summer-2025-134629666.html

24. Southforker – Hamptons & Shelter Island Easter Menus: https://southforker.com/2025/04/14/15-hamptons-and-shelter-island-easter-menus-no-bunny-can-resist/

25. Reddit – LongIslandEats (Infatuation Hamptons Guide): https://www.reddit.com/r/LongIslandEats/comments/1kwuajb/the_best_restaurants_in_the_hamptons_the/

26. Gurney’s Resorts – Gigi’s Montauk Dining: https://www.gurneysresorts.com/montauk/dining/gigis

27. Jean-Georges – Topping Rose House: http://www.jean-georges.com/restaurants/united-states/bridgehampton/jean-georges-at-topping-rose-house

28. James Lane Post – New Openings East End Summer 2025: https://jameslanepost.com/new-openings-on-the-east-end-whats-in-store-for-summer-2025/05/19/2025/Hamptons-News-Happenings

29. Resy Blog – Ultimate Resy Guide to The Hamptons: https://blog.resy.com/2025/05/the-ultimate-resy-guide-to-the-hamptons/

30. Hamptons Social – Coche Comedor: https://hamptons-social.com/coche-comedor/

31. Carissa’s The Bakery – Official Site: https://www.carissasthebakery.com/

32. Expedia – The 1770 House Restaurant & Inn: https://www.expedia.com/East-Hampton-Hotels-The-1770-House-Restaurant-Inn.h1085655.Hotel-Information

33. Modern Luxury – River Oaks Guide (Houston): https://www.modernluxury.com/river-oaks-guide/

34. Cititour – Hamptons Summer Dining 2025: https://cititour.com/NYC_News/Hamptons-Summer-Dining-2025-Where-to-Eat-Now/9519

35. Il Buco – Il Buco al Mare: https://ilbuco.com/pages/il-buco-al-mare

36. Wine Spectator – Lulu Kitchen & Bar Spotlight: https://www.winespectator.com/articles/restaurant-spotlight-lulu-kitchen-and-bar-long-island-sag-harbor

37. Southforker – Carissa’s James Beard Semifinalist: https://southforker.com/2025/02/24/carissas-named-sweet-semifinalist-with-james-beard/

38. 27East – Bostwick’s History: https://www.27east.com/food-drinks/new-address-but-same-approach-1393470/

39. Il Buco – Our Story: https://ilbuco.com/pages/our-story

40. Highway Restaurant – Official Site: https://highwayrestaurant.com/

41. Carissa’s The Bakery – Pantigo Location: https://www.carissasthebakery.com/location/carissas-the-bakery-pantigo/

42. Coche Comedor – Official Site: https://cochecomedor.com/

43. Dopo La Spiaggia – Official Site: https://www.dopolaspiaggia.com/

44. Apple Maps – Bostwick’s Chowder House: https://maps.apple.com/place?address=277%20Pantigo%20Rd%2C%20East%20Hampton%2C%20NY%2011937%2C%20United%20States&coordinate=40.9681231%2C-72.1671732&name=Bostwick’s%20Chowder%20House&place-id=IB38689160ADB7E52&_provider=9902

45. Gurney’s Resorts – About Us: https://www.gurneysresorts.com/about

46. PitchBook – Gurney’s Resorts Profile: https://pitchbook.com/profiles/company/350512-39

47. Amalfi Hamptons – Official Site: https://www.amalfihamptons.com/